New VirtualHost takes control of DirectoryRoot

OK. I have been banging my head. This isn't the first time I have configured VirtualHosts but I have never come across this problem.

I have a single host on my newly setup linode.

pellacrosscountry.com
# domain: pellacrosscountry.com
# public: /var/www/pellacrosscountry.com/public_html/

 <virtualhost *:80=""># Admin email, Server Name (domain name), and any aliases
  ServerAdmin runrobrun@gmail.com
  ServerName pellcrosscountry.com
  ServerAlias www.pellacrosscountry.com
  ServerAlias pelladutchxc.com
  ServerAlias www.pelladutchxc.com

  # Index file and Document Root (where the public files are located)
  DirectoryIndex index.html index.php
  DocumentRoot /var/www/pellacrosscountry.com/public_html/

  # Log file locations
  LogLevel warn
  ErrorLog  /var/www/pellacrosscountry.com/log/error.log
  CustomLog /var/www/pellacrosscountry.com/log/access.log combined</virtualhost> 

Works find and dandy.

I set up and enabled a second virtual host gatewaynazarene.org

# domain: gatewaynazarene.org
# public: /var/www/gatewaynazarene.org/public_html/

 <virtualhost *:80=""># Admin email, Server Name (domain name), and any aliases
  ServerAdmin runrobrun@gmail.com
  ServerName  gatewaynazarene.org
  ServerAlias www.gatewaynazarene.org

  # Index file and Document Root (where the public files are located)
  DirectoryIndex index.html index.php
  DocumentRoot /var/www/gatewaynazarene.org/public_html/
  # Log file locations
  LogLevel warn
  ErrorLog  /var/www/gatewaynazarene.org/log/error.log
  CustomLog /var/www/gatewaynazarene.org/log/access.log combined</virtualhost> 

As soon as I make this change and enable the site then restart apache the original domain pellacrosscountry.com pulls up the html file stored in the gatewaynazarene.org DocumentRoot? I have dug through configurations in the apache2.conf that I can think of.

Any ideas? Interestingly enough if I enable a third site then pellacrosscountry.com points to that one. Probably something really stupid but I can't seem to get it figured out.

Rob